thinking makes it so

There is grandeur in this view of life…

Everything happens for a reason

with one comment

Marilyn Monroe (with Jane Russell)

Marilyn Monroe (with Jane Russell)

I would be surprised if Marilyn Monroe was the first to say that everything happens for a reason. This is apparently her take on things:

I believe that everything happens for a reason. People change so that you can learn to let go, things go wrong so that you appreciate them when they’re right, you believe lies so you eventually learn to trust no one but yourself, and sometimes good things fall apart so better things can fall together.

She certainly wasn’t the last to say it. I’ve just Googled everything happens for a reason and come up with over 800,000 hits. Admittedly a few of them could have been I’m not sure it’s true that EHFAR or there are those who think that EHFAR, but I doubt if they’re in the majority. EHFAR is after all one of happyology’s favourite mantras.

Now and again I have heard EHFAR described as a ‘useful lie’. But I don’t think it is even that. It doesn’t seem a particularly helpful thing to think.

The problem is that it can be confused with other, rather more reasonable, beliefs.

For example: every event has a cause.

I am not saying I think it’s true that every event has a cause, or that it’s not. But it could be true. If we knew for certain that it was true – or, conversely, we know for certain that it was not true – then we would know something quite profound about the universe.

The point for now is purely that reasons and causes are very different things. They can be confused though because both can be answers to ‘why?’-type questions.

Perhaps closer to the spirit of what EHFAR-believers may be after, there is the belief that we can learn from things that happen to us; and the related belief that it is a good thing to learn from things that happen to us. I have no problem with this kind of language.

We can translate all Marilyn’s examples:

When people change it can help you learn to let go. When things go wrong it helps you appreciate when things go right. If you find yourself believing enough lies you may eventually learn to trust no one but yourself. When good things fall apart it can sometimes be an opportunity for better things to fall together.

This may not read as cosy as the original, but it avoids the anthropomorphism. Why on earth should the animate and inanimate universe be organised the way it is so as to teach us things? Even more to the point, why should the animate and inanimate universe around me be organised the way it is so as to teach me things?

It is a short hop from here to the pernicious rationale that bad luck and suffering are inflicted on us as punishment.

Of course some things happen for a reason. And sometimes the reason (as in intention) and the cause are hard to separate – for example a baby being born because it was conceived.

But (luckily for babies) not everything is a baby. When things happen for no reason it helps us appreciate that we are not the centre of the universe. A useful thing to be reminded of.

© Chris Lawrence 2010.

Advertisements

Written by Chris Lawrence

12 August 2010 at 6:04 am

Posted in Ethics

Tagged with , , ,

One Response

Subscribe to comments with RSS.

  1. Chris – Thank you for this. For once I find myself feeling that your own assessment of an issue is rather quite mild compared to my own. Perhaps it is because I was raised with the idea that God has some Great Plan that we are meant to figure out and fulfil. This is fine for the good or neutral things that happen in life, but creates a considerable assault on ones concept of a loving God when something cruel or senseless happens.

    And paradoxically, although it opens the way conveniently to blame the victim as you suggest, it also relieves one of any responsibility for making things better or different next time.

    The most wonderful insight into this came from a Spanish mother who had lost her young son. She said she began to recover when she stopped asking “porque?” (why?) and asked instead “por qua?” (what can I accomplish with this?)

    Thank you again for a liberating post. I do like to learn from struggling with different points of view, but once in a while, it is terrific to read something with which I enthusiastically agree 100%

    Terry

    Terry

    12 August 2010 at 4:44 pm


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: